Twelve South

BookBook Case For iPhone 5: Like its Predecessor, Only Better [Review]

I was a big fan of the original BookBook case for iPhone 4 and iPhone 4S, but it did have a number of drawbacks that its creators, Twelve South, needed to address — such as the lack of a camera cutout on the back of the case. With the iPhone 5 version, however, drawbacks have been eliminated.

For those of you who are unfamiliar with the BookBook, is a luxury, handmade leather wallet case that’s designed to look like a pocket-sized, vintage book. In addition to carrying and protection your iPhone 5, it carries up to four credit cards and has space for cash. BookBook for iPhone 5 comes in vintage brown and classic black, and it’s priced at $59.99.

The Good
The BookBook really is a beautiful case. I said the same about its predecessor, and it’s also true this time around. The high-quality leather that goes into making this case look like a vintage book is gorgeous, and it only gets better looking over time. Yes, it’ll scratch, and you’ll probably spill things on it or get it wet in the rain. But this only adds to its unique look and makes the BookBook feel like it’s really yours.

The leather also makes this case incredibly strong. It’s soft and smooth to the touch, but thick and durable enough to take a good battering without falling apart or allowing your iPhone to get damaged. As opposed to holding your iPhone with a leather frame, like its predecessor, BookBook for iPhone 5 has a plastic shell inside it, which only makes the case feel even more protective.

This also allows the case to become thinner. If you’ve owned the previous BookBook, you’ll instantly notice the different in size, which is much easier on your pocket. It also means buttons, ports and switches are easier to get at. The mute switch on the old BookBook wasn’t easy to get at, because the leather around it got in the way. The plastic case in this version means that’s no longer a problem.

The biggest improvement, however, comes with the camera cutout on the back of the case. The original BookBook didn’t have this, and you had to slide your iPhone out of the case slightly whenever you wanted to take a picture. Needless to say this became quite a frustration over time.

The BookBook will hold three to four credit cards in its pockets quite comfortably, but if you attempt to jam more in, they can be a little difficult to get out. One of the credit card pockets is transparent, which is ideal for a driver’s license of ID. There’s also a larger pocket at the back of the case that’s great for holding bills and notes, and other cards that you can’t fit into the front pockets.

The Bad
Almost all of the gripes I had with the original BookBook — its lack of camera cutout and the difficulty using its mute switch — have been ironed out with this model. With that being the case, I don’t have many negative things to say about it.

But there is one thing: there’s no way to keep the BookBook closed. You don’t have to worry about your credit cards or iPhone falling out — these are all securely held inside — but if you drop your device, there’s a good chance the front cover will flap open and leave your iPhone’s display exposed. Twelve South could solve this with a simple elastic band. It might make the case look a little less sophisticated, but it’s added peace of mind.

The Verdict
BookBook for iPhone 5 is, again, a vast improvement over its predecessor. All of the previous problems have been ironed out, and some nice improvements have been made to its size and its design. As iPhone wallet cases go, this is one of the nicest there is. It’s strong and robust, and it looks fantastic. It might be priced at $60, but its well worth it.

Review: Twelve South’s BookBook case for iPhone 5

Following up its popular BookBook case for previous generations of the iPhone, Twelve South has released a new BookBook that is designed to fit the taller and thinner iPhone. The case, which we have been testing for approximately a week, not only is redesigned to fit Apple’s new iPhone design, but adds some new features as well. The TwelveSouth BookBook iPhone 5 case rolls two unique iPhone case ideas into one: an iPhone case that looks like a mini, vintage book cover, and an iPhone case that includes the functionality of a basic wallet.

Build quality and protection:  The case looks great and unique and definitely fits Twelve South’s goals of making it look like a classic book. The quality of the leather book-like cover’s materials (Twelve South says it’s made from genuine leather) is solid so the case should last a long time and survive drops and scratches. However, a big downside to the BookBook’s book-cover like design is that the front flap does not stay shut. When you leave it on a table or out in the open, your iPhone’s display will mostly be exposed. However, the flap easily shuts if it is pressed down (like it would be in a pocket).

Your iPhone 5, itself, will sit in a hard plastic frame. This frame keeps the iPhone tight in place. This is an improvement over the iPhone 4/4S BookBook model which somewhat loosely (but sufficiently) held your iPhone 4/4S in a pouch-like setup. The hard plastic frame will protect your iPhone 5′s four corners from being dented upon impact with a floor (for example). However, the plastic does not seem raised high enough above the display in order to protect your iPhone’s screen if it were to fall flat on a surface. The plastic leaves room for access to the headphone jack, Lightning connector port, speakers, front camera, and top sleep/wake button.

Usage: Following up its popular BookBook case for previous generations of the iPhone, Twelve South has released a new BookBook that is designed to fit the taller and thinner iPhone. The case, which we have been testing for approximately a week, not only is redesigned to fit Apple’s new iPhone design, but adds some new features as well. The TwelveSouth BookBook iPhone 5 case rolls two unique iPhone case ideas into one: an iPhone case that looks like a mini, vintage book cover, and an iPhone case that includes the functionality of a basic wallet.

Build quality and protection:  The case looks great and unique and definitely fits Twelve South’s goals of making it look like a classic book. The quality of the leather book-like cover’s materials (Twelve South says it’s made from genuine leather) is solid so the case should last a long time and survive drops and scratches. However, a big downside to the BookBook’s book-cover like design is that the front flap does not stay shut. When you leave it on a table or out in the open, your iPhone’s display will mostly be exposed. However, the flap easily shuts if it is pressed down (like it would be in a pocket).

Your iPhone 5, itself, will sit in a hard plastic frame. This frame keeps the iPhone tight in place. This is an improvement over the iPhone 4/4S BookBook model which somewhat loosely (but sufficiently) held your iPhone 4/4S in a pouch-like setup. The hard plastic frame will protect your iPhone 5′s four corners from being dented upon impact with a floor (for example).

However, the plastic does not seem raised high enough above the display in order to protect your iPhone’s screen if it were to fall flat on a surface. The plastic leaves room for access to the headphone jack, Lightning connector port, speakers, front camera, and top sleep/wake button.

Usage: Using the iPhone 5 while in the BookBook case is not as easy as using the iPhone 5 in a non-book/wallet case. It is still usable however. When using the case, I tend to either use the iPhone in one hand, gripping the right side of the iPhone in the BookBook. This felt slightly unwieldy in the beginning, but I got used to it overtime. Those who want more support while using their iPhone with a single thumb may find themselves gripping the iPhone on the right (as described above), but also holding the left BookBook flap with their other hand.

Typing with the iPhone 5 in portrait mode in the BookBook, in my tests, is best done with a single thumb or finger. Typing with two thumbs, as I like to do while using other cases or no case, is difficult and requires you to reach your other hand in a sometimes uncomfortable position. For those who truly like typing in portrait with two thumbs, I recommend folding back the BookBook’s wallet flap. This will take some time getting used to because the wallet flap, by design, will want to flap back up, but it is definitely usable. Usage, gaming, and typing in the landscape position is seamless and even better than without a case because the BookBook provides a nice grip to hold on to.

Camera access:
A notable downside of the iPhone 4/4S BookBook case is that it does not feature an opening for the rear camera. Instead, users were able to slide their iPhone 4/4S up to take a picture. Not a deal breaker, but still less convenient than having a true camera opening. The iPhone 5 model solves that with a proper camera  opening for the iPhone 5′s camera sensor and LED flash. The case does not seem to get in the way of the camera and your picture taking whatsoever. The front facing FaceTime camera on the iPhone 5 is not blocked whatsoever while the flap is open.

Taking photos using the iPhone’s volume up button is possible, but, with this case, it is much easier to just use the iPhone 5′s software camera button. If you will be taking video with the iPhone 5 in the BookBook for long amounts of time, we recommend using the feature in the landscape position while holding your iPhone in the BookBook with two hands.

As a wallet: 
The BookBook won’t make a true wallet replacement, but it will allow you to take some of your most important cards (and some cash) with you for days that you do not need your true wallet. The BookBook for iPhone 5 features three main card slots. They are meant to hold one card each, but I was able to easily place and remove two cards in each slot. Three is possible, but at that point it is difficult to remove the cards, so I don’t recommend doing that unless you absolutely need to. A fourth slot with a clear front is also available. I think most people will use this slot for their ID or driver’s license. There is also a large slot behind the cards that is ideal for holding some cash. I don’t recommend keeping coins in there: they will probably fall out easily.

Wrap-up: 
The iPhone 5 BookBook is an excellent case for those who are a fan of the case’s vintage, book-like design. The basic wallet functionality for cards and cash is a very nice convenience, and the case does offer basic-to-medium level protection for the daily iPhone user in non-heavy-duty work environments. For fans of the BookBook case for previous generations of the iPhone that are looking to get a case for their new iPhone 5, the new BookBook will be a great option. Over previous designs, your iPhone will now be held in a more sturdy position and the rear-camera opening is a very important enhancement. We recommend the BookBook for iPhone 5 for those who are fans of previous versions, for those who enjoy book-style cases, or for those who want the connivence of keeping your most important cards and cash with your iPhone.